A COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN THE MALE ATHLETE AND MALE NONATHLETE LEVEL FOR DIFFERENCE PERFORMING PHYSICAL ACTIVITIES A CASE STUDY OF PHYSICAL EDUCATION STUDENTS

http://dx.doi.org/10.31703/gpessr.2023(VI-I).05      10.31703/gpessr.2023(VI-I).05      Published : Dec 2023
Authored by : Mehwish Manzoor

05 Pages : 33-40

    Abstract

    The daily performance of physical activities has lots of benefits in our lives. Exercise and physical activity during adolescence may positively effect physical fitness levels and body composition. If a person engages him/herself in physical activities will remain physically fit and can maintain a healthy body composition which is the key to life. This research is based on male colleges of northern Punjab. There is a total of 112 male colleges in northern Punjab from which 21 colleges were selected and 210 participators and non-participators were collected. Four physical activities were compared speed, general endurance, flexibility, and power. This research revealed that the participants have more stamina as compared to non-participants in terms of speed and flexibility. The general endurance and power levels were same in the both groups. The mean difference in the speed is 11.58095 seconds and a general endurance of 2.91905 feet was found in both groups. The flexibility mean difference is 0.29381 centimeters and power 0.22019 feet were obtained in participators and non-participants

    Key Words

    Physical Activity, Performance, Athlete, Non-Athlete

    Introduction

    Any healthy lifestyle must include physical activity, and this applies to more than just physical well-being. Making a good connection between physical exercises and raising student accomplishment in the classroom could be the only way to demonstrate the value of exercise and physical education in our academic communities.

    Studies have discovered beneficial relationships between academic success. The academic success of students should demonstrate their readiness to begin post-compulsory education. However, it is unknown how much academic success affects starting post-compulsory education Castelli DM, Hillman CH, Buck SM, Erwin HE. (2007). 

    When students started in post-compulsory education, we looked at the relationships between academic achievement and physical exercise. The union contract for New York City (NYC) states that the maximum number of pupils in the gym at one time for physical education in high school is 50, but there is currently no such restriction for younger grades. (NYC Teacher Contract, 2018).

    Exercise and physical activity during adolescence may positively affect physical fitness levels and body composition. If a person engages him/herself in physical activities will remain physically fit and can maintain a healthy body composition which is the key to life (Ruiz et al., 2011).

    Andersen, M. P.,(2017), Physical activity sort of motion that quickens your respiration and pulse rate is considered to be physically active. Your general well-being and health will benefit from physical activity. It provides advantages for people of all ages, such as lowering the chance of developing long-term illnesses, enhancing sleep, boosting power, and enhancing both one's physical and mental health.

    Choi, S. M., Sum, K. W. R., (2021), People may simply increase their daily activity using simple approaches, which will help them attain the essential exercise levels. Lack of exercise is one of the key indicators of risk for illnesses that are not communicable death. Those who are not sufficiently or insufficiently active have a 22% to 32% greater risk of passing away than those who are suitably active.

    This represents the valuing element in the symbiosis with physical education, both activities becoming permanent during the entire period of education of the young generation. "The fact that the formation of modern humans supposes his development from a physical, social, intellectual, ethical and aesthetical point of view must be kept in mind, in connection to the demands of the society and according to his aptitudes, thus leading to an increase of his standard of living and of a social development" (Dacica & Colab, 2012).

     Physical Education is expected to have an impact on learning outcomes, namely changes in student behavior. This change in behavior should embrace all the potential in children that can be developed through education. One of them is physical education, which is an integral part of overall education and aims to develop aspects of physical fitness, movement skills, critical thinking skills, social skills, reasoning, emotional stability, action morals, aspects of a healthy lifestyle, and the introduction of a clean environment through selected physical, sporting and health activities that are planned systematically in order to achieve national education goals. Physical education is an important part of the education system (Juliantine, 2016). 

    Literature Review

    Tomporowski, McCullick, Pendleton, and Pesce, (2007), Understanding the effects of PA on students' mental activity, classroom behavior, and academic performance has received a lot of scholarly attention due to the significant negative effects on educational practices at the population level.

    According to Martin (2010) examining the literature relating to „physical activity, fitness, and academic achievement? provided the following key points: The large majority of university-based, internationally published research in this field has found a positive association between children's physical activity participation and academic achievement. In 2018, the World Health Organization's (WHO) Global Strategy on Physical Activity deployed a slight variation of Caspersen's definition. Instead of activity resulting in energy expenditure, the WHO referred to a bodily movement that "requires energy expenditure".

    Bartholomew, J. B., Morrison, D., &Ciccolo, J. T. (2005), Regular physical activity, such as walking, cycling, wheeling, doing sports, or active recreation, provides significant benefits for health. Some physical activity is better than doing none. By becoming more active throughout the day in relatively simple ways, people can easily achieve the recommended activity levels. Physical inactivity is one of the leading risk factors for non-communicable disease mortality. People who are insufficiently active have a 20% to 30% increased risk of death compared to people who are sufficiently active

    According to WHO in 2018, any physical activity based on skeletal muscles that use energy is considered to be intense exercise. Physical exercise includes all forms of movement, whether they are performed for fun, as a means of transit to and from destinations, or as part of work. Intense and moderate physical activity are both good for your health. The act of running, cycling, swimming, sports, physical recreation, and playing are all popular activities that everyone may undertake for enjoyment regardless of skill.

    The following major elements, according to Martin (2010), were revealed by reviewing the research on "physical activity, fitness, and academic success" The overwhelming mostly of school-based, widely disseminated research in this area has discovered a beneficial relationship between kids' engagement in physical exercise and academic success. Caspersen's definition was somewhat modified In 2017 for the World Health Organization's (WHO) Global Strategy on Increasing Physical Activity. The WHO refers to a bodily movement that "requires energy spending" as opposed to an activity that uses up energy.

    Thomas, Nelson, and Silverman (2015). Regular physical activity, such as riding a bike, participating in sports, or taking part in active leisure, has a favorable effect on well-being. It is better to exercise some than none.

    Physical Exercise Categories

    Aerobic exercise, bone and muscle repairing, stretching, and strengthening bones are among the five basic categories of physical activity.

    Aerobic Exercise

    Tinazci, EAlrefai, and Musa (2019), Your legs and arms, as well as other big muscles, are moved during aerobic exercise. Aerobic exercise includes things like running, swimming, walking, biking, dancing, and performing jumping jacks. The term "endurance activity" also applies to aerobic exercise. According to Tomporowski, Davis, Miller, and Naglieri, (2008), Your heart beats more quickly during aerobic exercise. Furthermore, this kind of exercise makes you breathe more heavily. Regular aerobic exercise strengthens and improves the function of both your lungs and your heart over time. 

    Muscles-Strengthening

     According to the American College of Sports Medicine 2019, Exercise for muscle development is a voluntary endeavor that uses resistance bands, machines for weightlifting, hand-held dumbbells, or the weight of one's own body (such as push-ups or sit-ups). Troiano, Berrigan, and Dodd (2008) described that the developing field of muscle-strengthening exercise epidemiology is described from this current point of view. Turner, E. O., &Mangual Figueroa, A. (2019), The worldwide physical activity recommendations, which previously prioritized aerobic physical activity (running, jogging, playing indoor games, etc.), have recently included a muscle-strengthening exercise to their list of recommended activities. First, we define this term and examine this inclusion

    Presses with a Standing Dumbbell Above

    Thomas, J. R., Nelson, J. K., & Silverman, S. J. (2015), Compound workouts, which employ several muscles and joints, are the best type of exercise for those with busy schedules since they work on different areas of the body simultaneously.

    Chacón-Cuberos, R., Castro-Sánchez, Zurita Ortega, F. (2019). Freestanding overhead presses, which also strengthen your upper back as well as your core, are one of the best exercises for shoulders.

    Material and Methods

    This research is based on male colleges of northern Punjab. There is a total of 112 male colleges in northern Punjab from which 21 colleges were selected according to equal proportion from each district. Data were gathered from the physical education department of each college. An equal sample size of performers and non-participants (Ten students) was selected from each physical education department.

    Table 1

    Total and Selected Number of Male Colleges

    Division

    Districts

    Total male colleges

    Selected male colleges

    Lahore

    Lahore

    18

    3

    Shekhapura

    6

    1

    Sargodha

    Sargodha

    15

    3

    Mianwali

    6

    1

    Sahiwal

    Okara

    7

    1

    Pakistan

    3

    1

    Rawalpindi

    Rawalpindi

    21

    4

    Jehlum

    6

    1

    Gujranwala

    Sialkot

    8

    1

    Narowal

    3

    1

    Faisalabad

    Faisalabad

    15

    3

    Chinnot

    4

    1

    Total

     

    112

    21

    Sample Size

    This study is based on Bachelor in Art (B.A) and Bachelor in Science (BSc) colleges. 21 Male' colleges were selected. 210 participators and 210  non-participators of physical education students at the college level. The difficulty and complexities of the respondents were removed, prior to actual data collection. Ten participants and ten non-participators were selected from each college

    Variables

    Physical activities have various shapes in the modern world. In the research, four physical activities were selected speed, general endurance, flexibility, and power. The measurements for all activities were performed and their data were collected. Those test tools and units are given below


     

    Table 2

    Tools and Units of the Variables

    Test

    Tool

    Unit

    Speed

    200 m Running

    Second

    General endurance

    Jogging

    Feet

    Flexibility

    Sit & reach box

    Centimeter

    Power

    Standing Long Jump

    Feet

    Statistical analysis

    The present study utilized descriptive as well as inferential statistics. The box and whisker plots are applied for outliers' detection and the normality test is supported with a histogram. A T-test was used for the comparison of physical activity data of participators and non-participators. The data was analyzed by using the (SPSS-23 version).

    Results and discussion

    Table 3

    Age of the Participators

    Age

    Male

    Participators

    Non-Participators

     

    F

    %

    f

    %

    >20 Years

    40

    19.047

    41

    19.523

    21-25 Years

    164

    78.095

    162

    77.142

    26-30 Years

    6

    2.857

    4

    1.904

    30- Above Years

    0

    0

    3

    1.428

     


    Table 02 shows that 19.047% of participators and 19.523%  non-participators age was less 20 years, 78.095% of participators and 77.142%  non-participators age was 21-25 years, 2.857% of participators and 1.904%  non-participators age was 25-30 years, 0.0% of participators and 1.428% non-participators age was less 30-above years.

    Table 4

    Socioeconomics Class

     

    Male

    Option

    Participators

    Non-Participators

     

    F

    %

    F

    %

    Lower

    7

    3.333

    7

    4.285

    Lower Middle

    21

    10.0

    21

    9.047

    Middle

    118

    56.190

    118

    55.238

    Upper Middle

    49

    23.333

    49

    20.476

    Upper

    15

    7.142

    15

    10.0

    Total

    210

    100.0

    210

    100.0

     


    Table 04 shows that 3.333% of participators and 14.285% of non-participators' socioeconomic class was lower, 10.0% of participators and 9.047% of non-participators' socioeconomic class was lower middle, 56.190% of participators and 55.238% of non-participators' socioeconomic class was middle, 23.333% of Male participators and 20.476% non-participators socioeconomic class was upper middle, 7.142% of participators and 10.0%  non-participators socioeconomic class was upper.

    Table 5

    Particular Game Participation

     

    Male

    Option

    Participators

    Non-Participators

     

    F

    %

    F

    %

    Cricket

    73

    34.761

    52

    24.761

    Football

    55

    26.190

    22

    10.476

    Badminton

    31

    14.761

    35

    16.666

    Other

    51

    24.285

    101

    48.095

    Total

    210

    100.0

    210

    100.0

     


    Table 5.10 shows that 34.761% of participators and 24.761% of non-participators particular game was Cricket, 26.190% of participators and 10.476% of non-participators particular game was Football, 14.761% of participators and 16.666%  non-participators particular game was Badminton, 24.285% of participators and 48.095%  non-participators particular game was other.

    Table 6

    Group Statistics

     

    Type

    N

    Mean

    Std. Deviation

    Std. Error Mean

    Speed

    Participators

    210

    22.0381

    4.83097

    .33337

    Non-participators

    210

    33.6190

    10.62396

    .73312

    Endurance

    Participators

    210

    69.2524

    18.75728

    1.29438

    Non-participators

    210

    72.1714

    18.76853

    1.29515

    Flexibility

    Participators

    210

    3.2969

    .61334

    .04232

    Non-participators

    210

    3.0031

    .54623

    .03769

    Power

    Participators

    210

    3.6969

    .56280

    .03884

    Non-participators

    210

    3.4767

    2.50729

    .17302

     


    Table 06 indicates that the total number of participators and non-participators was 210, the mean speed was 22.0381 seconds with a standard deviation of 4.83097 seconds for participators and 33.6190 with 10.62396 seconds. The average general endurance of 69.25.24 feet with a standard deviation of 18.75725 feet for participators and 72.1714 feet with a standard deviation of 18.76853 feet for non-participators was recorded. The mean of 3.2969 centimeters with a standard deviation of 0.61334 centimeters for participators and the mean of 3.0031 centimeters with a standard deviation of 0.54623 was achieved for flexibility. An average of 3.6969 feet with a 0.56280 feet standard deviation for participators and a mean of 3.4767 feet with a standard deviation of 2.5029 was obtained for power.

    Table 7

    Independent Samples Test

     

    t

    Df

    Sig

    Mean difference

    Std.Error

    95% Confidence Interval of the Difference

     

    Upper

    Lower

    Speed

    -14.380

    418

    0.000

    -11.58095

    .80536

    -13.16401

    -9.99789

    Endurance

    -1.594

    418.000

    0.112

    -2.91905

    1.83107

    -6.51830

    .68021

    Flexibility

    5.184

    412.510

    0.000

    .29381

    .05668

    .18240

    .40522

    Power

    1.242

    418.000

    0.216

    .22019

    .17732

    -.12920

    .56958

     


    Table no 06 describes that speed has a t-test value of -14.380 with a degree of freedom of 418. Its p-value is 0.000 indicating the significant difference in the speed of participators and non-participators. The T-test value for general endurance is -1.594 along with a degrees of freedom value of 412.510, its p-value is 0.115 which is greater than the specified level of significance value (0.05) indicating no significant difference in the means of general endurance for participators and non-participators. Flexibility has a t-test value of 5.184 with degrees of freedom of 412.510, and a p-value of 0.000 shows the significant difference in the mean flexibility of participators and non-participators. The power possesses a t-value of 1.242 along 418 degrees of freedom, its p-value is 0.216 implies that there is no difference between the means of the power of the participators and non-participators.

    Conclusion

    The study is conducted to test the levels of performing physical activities between the participators and non-participators of male students of the physical education department. This research revealed that the speed level was not same for the both groups the speed of the participators was better than the non-participators.  It was also determined the general endurance level for participators and non-participators was the same, there was not good difference in the general endurance for both groups. The flexibility level of the participators was extremely better than non-participators. Participators were found efficient as compared to non-participators. Power of the both groups was not different, their power strength was the same. Sports participation was reported in a positive relationship with health and academic achievement. Sports participation may improve cognitive health leading to improved academic achievement. Previous studies have provided evidence that sports participation has a positive association with cognitive and physical health. This study has examined the relationship between sports and academic achievement. 

    Recommendations

    Many future studies are recommended based on this study's limitations and findings. For instance, a qualitative study is recommended to profoundly understand the physical activity phenomenon in academic achievement. The qualitative part is essential in addition to the quantitative section. Future qualitative studies that focus on understanding the weak association between attitude and subjective norms with intention toward physical activity are also recommended. Furthermore, conducting this study at an international level to compare different Physical activity & sports would be beneficial to a better understanding of this phenomenon.

References

  • Andersen, M. P., Starkopf, L., Sessa, M., Mortensen, R. N., Vardinghus-Nielsen, H., Bøggild, H., Lange, T., & Torp-Pedersen, C. (2017). The indirect and direct pat

  • Bartholomew, J. B., Morrison, D., & Ciccolo, J. T. (2005). Effects of Acute Exercise on Mood and Well-Being in Patients with Major Depressive Di
  • Castelli, D. M., Hillman, C. H., Buck, S. M., & Erwin, H. E. (2007). Physical fitness and academic achievement in Third- and Fifth-Grade student
  • Chacón-Cuberos, R., Castro-Sánchez, M., Pérez-Turpin, J. A., Olmedo-Moreno, E. M., & Ortega, F. Z. (2019). Levels of physical activity are assoc
  • Choi, S. M., Sum, K. W. R., Leung, F. L. E., Ha, S. C. A., Sit, C., & Yeung, K. H. (2021). Predictors of Physical Activity Levels in University

Cite this article

    APA : Manzoor, M. (2023). A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students. Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review, VI(I), 33-40. https://doi.org/10.31703/gpessr.2023(VI-I).05
    CHICAGO : Manzoor, Mehwish. 2023. "A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students." Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review, VI (I): 33-40 doi: 10.31703/gpessr.2023(VI-I).05
    HARVARD : MANZOOR, M. 2023. A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students. Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review, VI, 33-40.
    MHRA : Manzoor, Mehwish. 2023. "A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students." Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review, VI: 33-40
    MLA : Manzoor, Mehwish. "A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students." Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review, VI.I (2023): 33-40 Print.
    OXFORD : Manzoor, Mehwish (2023), "A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students", Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review, VI (I), 33-40
    TURABIAN : Manzoor, Mehwish. "A Comparative Study Between the Male Athlete and Male Non-Athlete Level for Difference Performing Physical Activities, A Case Study of Physical Education Students." Global Physical Education and Sports Sciences Review VI, no. I (2023): 33-40. https://doi.org/10.31703/gpessr.2023(VI-I).05